Saturday, September 26, 2009

Pattern Review - Simplicity 2603 Tank Top



Pattern Description: The ubiquitous "cardi wrap" pattern - Sleeveless top and cardigan jacket. I made the tank top.

Sizing: XXS-XL. I made a small.

Fabric Used: Birds of a Feather Jersey from Gorgeous Fabrics.

It's long since sold out, but there's a cute story that goes along with this fabric. I had fallen in love with it myself, so before I put it up on the site, I cut three yards with the idea of making a dress. This fabric sold like gangbusters. I think I sold out of it in one day. After it was gone, one customer called and emailed me that she was heartbroken. She wanted it so badly, she asked if I could call her if any more showed up. Well, it became a choice of "Do I keep it for myself or do I sell it to this nice lady?" I told her I had one piece left that was sitting in my private stash. She was so happy! She only needed 2 yards, so I cut that and (crying inside) sent it out to her. The fabric sat in my stash until last week, when I decided to try it for this pattern.

Needle/Notions Used: Stretch 75/11 needle, ProTricot fusible interfacing from Fashion Sewing Supply.

Did it look like the photo or drawing when you got through? Yes

How were the instructions? Bear with me for a moment, I'm going to rant. What is with the large pattern companies and their fekakte instructions??? Seriously. Here's the way they have you attach the collar band:
  1. apply interfacing to neck band front and back
  2. stitch interfaced front/back sections together
  3. attach interfaced neck band to garment
  4. stitch uninterfaced neck band sections together to make the facing
  5. Finish edge of facing
  6. pin band facing to neck band. Sew and understitch
  7. Turn facing to inside, press
  8. Working from the right side of garment, pin raw edge of facing over the neckline seam
  9. Top stitch
No no NO! Come on, people! (This is to the pattern companies, not you, dear reader) Get your instructions out of the 1970s. No one in RTW attaches a collar that way. For pete's sake, you sew the facing to the collar band, baste them together at the raw edge and sew or serge that that to the garment. It takes less time and gives you a cleaner finish with less chance of messing up. Sorry - can you tell I've had it up to my eyeballs with bad pattern instructions? This is why I almost never use them. And I'm sick to death of having to correct and apologize for them in classes. Grrrr....

Here's a picture of the neck band the way I attach it.

Construction Notes: I did a FBA. Other than the change noted above, I didn't do anything special. I serged all the seams and used a narrow zigzag stitch (.5 mm wide, 3.0 mm long) to sew the hems.

Any changes? Nope

Likes/Dislikes: I like the bra-friendly straps. They are nice and wide. I like the lines of this top. I'm debating about making the cardigan. It's so common these days on sewing sites, I don't know if I want to do that or something different. I have a wonderful pleated silk jersey in a matching turquoise that has been gracefully aging in my stash that I want to use to make a coordinating topper for this. I'll think about it and let you know what I decide.

Would you do it again? Would you recommend it? Probably and maybe. Like I say, I really dislike the instructions, but I like the bones of this top.

Conclusion: A good basic for your wardrobe. Here's a picture of the finished version.
Next up I think is the skirt to go with my bustier.

Happy sewing!

19 comments:

AuntieAllyn said...

Beautiful top . . . how did I miss THAT fabric?!!!!

Erica Bunker said...

I love that! What a great print!

Bunny said...

Gorgeous! Love how you placed the motifs.

Carolyn (Diary of a Sewing Fanatic) said...

Seriously...this is why most times I just go my own way! I mean really how much worse could I do doing it my own way than if I followed the instructions???

I love the tank! Who knew the pattern was hiding such a great top!!!

CarlaF-in Atlanta said...

I have the plus size pattern equivalent Simplicity 2598. I've copied your instruction for attaching the collar band and added them to the envelope. Your instructions seam a whole heck of alot easier. Thank you! Thank you!

CarlaF-in wet and soggy Atlanta

Joyce in NC said...

Like CarlaF, I also have the Plus size version S2598. I didn't really look at the top. I purchased it for the jacket. I agree the directions in some of the top 4 are just plain terrible.

Sew-4-Fun said...

Lovely top! I didn't even realise this pattern came with a tank because Simplicity no longer have line drawings on their website. {rolleyes} And I hear you on the instructions. While I know they are boilerplate you would think by 2009 they would have different instructions for knits vs wovens.

anita said...

Love this top in that beautiful fabric! Thanks so much for your instructions, Ann. I made this top too and really like it a lot. Now I can look forward to making it again following your logical steps rather than Simplicity's head-scratching ones. :)

uggbootdiva said...

I'm with carolyn - that top is awesome - I'll have to investigate your instructions a little more closely to understand what you are saying but anything that makes it quicker and easier - bring it on!

Pam Erny said...

This top is so fabulous.

I agree about the instructions...I think out-dated instructions are why some people are getting frustrated sewing knits. But knits are so easy and forgiving, and when you use contemporary techniques...the results are so great !

linda68701 said...

ok, I hear you that their instructions were problematic, but I need a couple of clarifying questions answered. Did you topstitch around the collar edge? How did you attach the facing to the wrong side? Thanks.

meli88a said...

Great top! I like your version of adding the facing SO MUCH better than the pattern company's version. Never thought of doing it your way before but it makes so much more sense!

Eugenia said...

I really love that top and, of course, the fabric is Gorgeous. I was thinking of buying this pattern for the cardi and hadn't even noticed the top - so now I must get this pattern. Incidentally, I read Sew4Fun's comment above and you might be interested to know that if you go to the Simplicity US website then click on the Union Jack, British flag at the top left hand of the page to go to the UK Simplicity website you will find that they still give you the front and back view line drawings for each of the patterns.

Lynne said...

Lovely fabric, and your directions for the collar facing? Spot on!

Linda T said...

That is a very nice pattern! And thank you! It is good to hear you complaining too. I am always complaining about the instructions. What are they thinking?

Great blouse!

Little Hunting Creek said...

Beautiful top - I also wonder how I missed this fabric! I know why you were crying when you let it go!

Rose said...

Wonderful! Thank you for 21st century instructions for an interfaced collar--I'll add them to my copy of the pattern.

Question: do you think that non-sewists will recognize the ubiquity of this the cardiwrap? I admit that I hesitated at making it, but I decided that non-sewists wouldn't recognize that it's amazingly popular.

Summerset said...

Late to the party, but yes I like the result of the top, and agree about the instructions. You win on two accounts with this one - you made a customer happy and you have a nice little top to wear with other pieces.

Lisette said...

Also have the plus version and am considering it for SWAP coming up. Great to know that the tank is a keeper too!